—Who stole your first kiss— (Thanks for Floof_Ball for the suggestion ^^)
Boy/Girl
Aries: Homicidal Liu/ Lulu

Taurus: BEN drowned/ Nurse Ann

Gemini: Hoodie/ Lazari (Older)

Cancer: Laughing Jack/ Laughing Jill

Leo: Slenderman/ Nightmare Ally

Virgo: Offenderman/ Sally[older] (i'm sorry for you :/ )

Libra: Masky/ Clockwork

Scorpio: Eyeless Jack/ Jane the killer

Sagitarius: Jeff the killer/ Nina the killer

Capricorn: Bloody painter/ Judge Angel

Aquarius: Ticci Toby/ Suicide Sadie

Pisces: Dark Link/ Killing Kate

So give me some suggestions don't be afraid to ask! And thanks for the 50 readers btw!!! I didn't think someone will read it so yeah bye!