Aries: Jeff the Killer

Taurus: BEN Drowned

Gemini: Eyeless Jack

Cancer: Ticci Toby

Leo: Jason the Toymaker

Virgo: Laughing Jack

Libra: Dark Link

Scorpio: Hoodie

Sagittarius: Slenderman (never thought he had it in him)

Capricorn: Candypop

Aquarius: Trenderman

Pisces: Dr. Smiley