Aries: Offenderman (oooo....)

Taurus: Nightmare Ally

Gemini: Eyeless Jack

Cancer: Masky

Leo: Splendorman (no...)

Virgo: Trenderman

Libra: Laughing Jack

Scorpio: Zalgo (uh oh...)

Sagittarius: Bloody Painter

Capricorn: Suicide Sadie

Aquarius: The Puppeteer

Pisces: Nina the Killer

Everyone: Slenderman (lol. We're all doomed)