Aries: Ticci Toby

Taurus: Slenderman (whaaaaaaaaaaaaaaat?)

Gemini: Candypop

Cancer: Masky

Leo: The Puppeteer

Virgo: Laughing Jack

Libra: Dark Link

Scorpio: Zalgo O~o

Sagittarius: Dr. Smiley

Capricorn: Hoodie

Aquarius: BEN Drowned

Pisces: Jeff the Killer (oh wow...)