Aries: Jeff The Killer

Taurus: Slenderman

Gemini: Clockwork

Cancer: Bloody Painter

Leo: BEN DROWNED

Virgo: Puppeteer

Libra: Laughing Jack

Scorpio: Jane The  Killer

Sagittarius: Ticci Toby

Capricorn: Hoodie

Aquarius: Masky

Pisces: Eyeless Jack

a/n: I will update this frequently.