This is out of all the pastas. Also I use a random generator to tell what signs get what creepypasta.

Aires:  Hoodie

Taurus: Lost Silver

Gemini: Jeff The Killer

Cancer: Bloody Painter

Leo: Sonic.EXE

Virgo: Doll Maker

Libra: Mr. Widemouth

Scorpio: BEN DROWNED

Sagittarius: Bloody Mary

Capricorn: Eyeless Jack

Aquarius: Hobo Heart

Pisces: Slenderman