Aries: Splendorman

Taurus: Hoodie

 Gemini: doesn't have one

 Cancer: Zalgo

 Leo: Slenderman

 Virgo: Laughing Jack

 Libra: Ticci Toby

 Scorpio: Masky

 Sagittarius: Eyeless Jack

 Capricorn: Jeff the killer

 Aquarius: Ben Drowned

Pisces: Offenderman (oof sorry Pisces)