Aries: Ben Drowned- a game console

Taurus: Sally- a stuffed bear

 Gemini: Toby- Waffles

 Cancer: Eyeless Jack- kidneys

 Leo: Slenderman- a mission

 Virgo: laughing Jack- eyes

 Libra: Jeff- knives

 Scorpio: Offenderman- a rose of your favorite color

 Sagittarius: Masky- a piece of cheesecake

 Capricorn: Trenderman- new clothes

 Aquarius: The rake- a human heart

Pisces: Zalgo- a sword