Slenderman:

You two were doing  a supply count when you noticed the mansion was low on food/water/etc. Slenderman nods and asks you to get said item.

"Alright, shouldn't take long. Love you."

You freeze as Slenderman perks. A long silence fills the room before Slender presses where his lips would be on your head.

"Don't be late. Love you too."

Jeff the Killer:

You two were goofing off after a night of killing.

Jeff did something adorably stupid, making you laugh. Jeff yells at you not to laugh at him, which only makes you smile.

"Relax idiot, I love you."

Both your eyes grow wide as you stare at each other.

Jeff then justs passes out

Masky:

Masky was venting to you about some stress that was building up over the week. It was very common for this to happen.

You were holding tea as Masky told you how he felt like nobody really cared for him.

"Masky, I know I'll sound like a broken record, but I love you."

Masky perked and turned to you.

"You... never said that."

After that your face would get red before Masky offers to cuddle, which ends the night.

Hoodie/Hoody (idk which it is):

Hoodie would be helping you make lunch for everyone (which is like... 20+ people).

Hoodie would be slightly struggling on the cooking part while you are sweeping the stage.

"You and your cooking."

"I love you too."

You and Hoodie pause before looking at each other.

"I-I love you too?"

You went back to cooking, clearly flustered. He meant to sarcastically make fun of you.

Ticci Toby:

You were sewing Toby's favorite hoodie back together after he accidently torn it. Toby was hugging his security pillow while you tightened the stitch.

Toby was carefully watching as he twitched his head.

"Are you almost done?"

"Yes I am Tobs. Have some patience, love."

Toby would perk up as you'd pause.

"I love you too!"

You smiled at Toby as you finished the stitch.