Eyeless Jack x Reader

2nd POV

Just like the night before, you were again, walking home late after work.
It was another cold night, your mind was on the strange boy you met, Eyeless Jack.
You knew he was the one going around town cutting people open, taking their kidneys and leaving them for dead.
It made you wonder to yourself, why didn't he kill you and take your kidneys as well?
Whatever the case was, you felt grateful he had saved you, you wanted to see him again.
You walked down the same alley way, the lights flickering as they did the night before.
There was a chalk outline of two bodies, where the two men EJ had killed were once laying.
You shuddered, but continued walking.
You took a short cut through a part of the woods, which led to your neighborhood.
The sounds of the wind rustling in the trees were all around you.
You kept your head down as you walked down the dirt path.
Suddenly you felt someone touch your side, you jumped and looked.
A quiet chuckle came from Eyeless Jack, who was standing next to you.
"Eyeless Jack! You bastard..." You said with a slight grin as your heart raced.
He nodded, "That would be me." He lifted up his mask a bit, showing a bright smile.
"I'm Y/N, Y/N L/N." You said, smiling as well.
EJ put his mask back down, "Pretty name, suits you." He replied.
You softly blushed as you turned away, "Yours does as well."
He chuckled, you started walking again, he followed.

10 minutes passed, you and EJ making conversation as he walked with you to your home.
You both entered through the back door, you sighed as you kicked of your shoes and hung your coat up.
The lights turned on and EJ looked around.
"Nice place, live by yourself?" He asked as he leaned against the wall.
You nodded, "All alone."
He watched as you went to the fridge, grabbing a soda and opening it to drink it.
"Told you you'd see me again." He said as he smiled under his mask.
You took a drink, then smiled softly, looking up at him.
"You did, and thanks again, for saving me...can I ask why you did it?" You questioned, your E/C eyes looking into the holes of his mask.
He made eye contact with you for a moment, then looked away.
He shrugged, "I really don't know."
Behind his mask, a tint of pink flashed across his cheeks.
You smiled again, then yawned.
"Damn, well good thing I don't have work tomorrow. I can sleep in." You mumbled to yourself as you set your soda down and rubbed your eyes.
EJ noticed them got off the wall.
"I'll let you get some sleep then." He said.
You nodded, he opened the back door and walked out.
"Will I...see you again?" You asked with a grin, standing at the door.
EJ chuckled as he looked at you, with one hand in his hoodie and one hand free, he lifted his mask all the way up.
Your eyes widened, "Woah..."
He didn't have any eyes, instead where his eyes should be it was all black, with a weird black liquid staining it, his hair was a dark brown.
You felt your stomach flutter, despite his unusual appearance, he was really attractive.
"You don't think I'm a monster?" He asked in a quiet, sad tone.
You gave him a look like he was an idiot, shaking your head.
"I don't think that. I mean, you do kill people, but for whatever reason you saved my life. I'm grateful for that and honestly, it only makes you more of an intriguing person that I want to get to know." You replied, looking directly into his 'eyes'.
EJ's heart beat fast at your words, he smiled, showing his sharp teeth.
"Well Y/N, you'll be seeing me a lot. There will be plenty and plenty of time for us to know each other." He said, putting his mask back over his face.
"Goodnight, Eyeless Jack." You said, staring to shut the door.
EJ turned away, "Rest well."
He then hopped your fence, disappearing once more into the night, of the forest.
You shut the door, feeling yourself blush.
"I think I might be in love with a cannibalistic killer."

——————
This is my last little short story for this book, it also marks the 5th Creepypasta book I've written.
Up next I'm writing a lemon book, then I think that'll be the end of my Creepypasta writing.
Thank you all for reading, vote and comment if you enjoyed.
-Ella