Slenderman

Slender gave you a diamond heart necklace 

Jeff the Killer

Jeff gave you a sapphire ring 

BEN Drowned 

BEN gave you a charm bracelet he made himself 

Masky

Masky gave you a camera to match his

Hoodie

Hoodie gave you topaz earrings 

Ticci Toby

Toby gave you a gold necklace with a diamond 

Laughing Jack

LJ gave you a pearl anklet 

Eyeless Jack

EJ gave you a ruby ring 

Glitchy Red

Red gave you silver purple earrings

Dark Link

Dark gave you a crystal earrings

I ran out of ideas, so yeah. But I made a picture of everything and I can't even upload it -.- I'm pissed, but yeah. So here you guys go! :D