Slenderman 

You two went as Jack and Sally

Jeff the Killer

You two went as Killer and Victim (I'm so original omg)

BEN Drowned

You two went as Zelda and BEN (bc he hates Link)

Masky

You two went as Miley Cyrus and Robin Thicke (I'm laughing rn)
 
Hoodie

You two went as Micky and Minnie :D

Ticci Toby

You two went as Fred and Wilma

Laughing Jack

You two went as Freddy Kreguer and Miss Freddy Krueger

Eyeless Jack

You two went as Popeye and Olive Oil

Glitchy Red 

You two went as Emily and Victor (I love this movie tbh)

Dark Link

You two went as Thing one and Thing two (He wanted to go as Adam and Eve)


A/N
Mind checking out my ask the cps book? If it gets to 250 reads, I'll post another chapter. :D