(A/N: This scenario is directed more towards my male readers. Also, I will be adding females to the scenarios in the upcoming updates, so stay tuned for that and if you would like a specific female pasta in these, please comment or private message me. Thank you all for reading and I hope you enjoy! Waffle out.)

Slenderman:

You were sitting cross-legged on your bed in the middle of a call with a few of your internet friends when Slenderman came into your room.

"(Y/N), can we talk?" He was in what was known as his illusion form so he hid his eyes behind his black bangs. You quickly ended the call and faced him.

"What's going on?" He fidgeted.

"Well, my starling..." Slender trailed off. After a minute of this continuing, you got up and took his hands in yours.

"Hey, Slender, you can tell me anything. I know I may not be the best to deal with and I'm not very good at consoling people, but I do try. Of course, I will especially try my hardest for you. I am in love with you, afterall," you chuckled. "I'm not very great with words either. Now what was it that was bothering you?"

"It was nothing." He smiled and pulled you onto bed with himself, planning on cuddling with you for the rest of the night.

Jeff The Killer:

"I just- I'm not sure about it anymore. I've never been with anyone before, let alone another guy!" Jeff vented to the other pastas.

"Well, do you love him?" The Expressionless chimed in.

"This is a guy's night out, what're you doing here?" Jeff sneered back, causing the others to laugh.

"It's her house." Masky chuckled.

"Well, do you?" She asked once again.

"Of course I do, but it's different when it's between someone of the same sex."

"Oh? And how's that so?" There was silence. "If you really loved him, you wouldn't let something like his gender stop you. Don't continue to play with his heart if you aren't ready for a commitment, Jeffrey." Jeff sighed, knowing she was right. He found himself to be foolish for thinking otherwise.

BEN Drowned:

BEN had been avoiding you for weeks on end- which caused for you to feel as if you did something to anger him. Once the sorrow had passed, you felt angered by him. Why would he just ignore you? After another week or so of this continuing, you were finally able to corner him.

"BEN, what the fuck is going on?" He looked around your arms as if for a means of escaping the situation.

"N-nothing, (Y/N)." He stuttered, you had him pinned to the wall with your arms at either side of him.

"It sure doesn't seem like nothing. Are you cheating on me or something?" Your voice quivered.

"No!"

"Then what, BEN? What did I do wrong, because whatever it was, I can fix it." Tears began overflowing your eyes.

"I just don't know if I can do this anymore." You dropped your hands from the wall.

"Why?" You nearly whispered.

"I-I don't know if the other pastas will support us. They might make fun of me, (Y/N)." At this point, he was looking down at the floor- as if he was ashamed of admitting.

"Your pride is worth more to you than I am?"

"No! Not at all!"

"Then what is it?" You sighed, wiping the tears from your face. "I love you, BEN. Maybe, just maybe, we can get through this together. I'm ready to give up everything I have for you, but are you willing to do the same? Because if you're not, we might have to separate." He reached out and pulled you into a kiss with him.

"I don't want to lose you," he sniffed. "I'm willing to, I promise. I love you."

Eyeless Jack:

You and Jack had gotten into an argument over his sexuality.

"I don't see why it even matters to you!" He yelled.

"You're my fucking boyfriend, Jack. That may not be a big deal to you, but it is to me." You argued.

"Then you can get out of my house, (Y/N)."

"This is my fucking house."

"Why are you being so difficult?!"

"Does what you said about you loving me mean nothing to you?" Tears started to cloud up your vision.

"No, I mean yes! It does matter, but this is different."

"How?" You threw your arms out.

"I-I," he stuttered, trying to gather an explanation.

"I thought you fell in love with me, Jack." After a few moments of silence, he began walking towards you. "Don't you dare touch me." Nonetheless, he pulled you into a fairly tight hug.

"I'm sorry, (Y/N). I'm really sorry about my incompetence. I love you for you."

Dr.Smiley:

"Hey, (Y/N)?"

"Yes, Smiley?" You hummed into his chest sleepily.

"What would happen if I decided I didn't want to be homosexual?" You let go of him and turned onto your back.

"First off, you can say the word 'gay', it's not really offensive. And well, if you've decided that you're uncomfortable with it- I'd be okay with your decision. Of course I'd be a bit upset from losing you, but I guess it's alright as long as you're still my friend. But just make sure it's your decision and that you're not pressured into it- or else this would have been meaningless." You laughed lightly before adding, "Just don't forget that I love you."

Dr.Smiley propped himself on his elbow and kissed your forehead, "I love you, too."

Ticci Toby:

"I honestly can not believe Jeff and Smiley, (Y/N)." Toby said, suddenly entering through your house.

"What'd they do now?" You asked a bit uninterested as Toby sat down next to you on the couch.

"They're dating men." He said, sounding disgusted by the thought.

"Toby?"

"Yeah?"

"You do realize that I'm a guy, right?" Toby was unpredictable but this was a whole new level of stupid for him.

"Nono, of course I do! It's just different. You're actually someone who's hot. Their boyfriends ,however, are not." You got up from your seat and headed towards the stairs. "Where are you going?"

"As flattered as I am, that was a really dumb joke."

"Then why are you laughing?~"

"Fuck off." With that, you stormed into your room.

Lost Silver:

"(Y/N)!" Silver thrust your front door open making you jump. You hurried to him and as you got closer, you noticed tears falling down his face.

"What's the matter?" You asked in a panicked sort of sense.

"W-wut if I've bin fauking being gaay?" He slurred. You could smell the alcohol on his breath. It wasn't often that Silver drank, but he couldn't handle his alcohol when he did.

"Silver, I don't even think that's possible for you."

"But, I luv yew! I cuold be."

"Want me to prove it to you?" He nodded and you shut the front door before dragging him to the bedroom.

Hoodie: (nibbles7192 wrote this one)

"It's not that I don't think I'm not gay, I'm just saying that Masky's pretty hot."

"Hoodie, what the fuck."

Masky:

"Hey, (Y/N). I... I don't think I'm homosexual." You looked up at him.

"What?"

"Don't get me wrong, you're pretty attractive. I don't even think I'm into people."

"So you're saying you're asexual?"

"Rather than asexual, I think I'm cheesecake-sexual." Masky pulls out a piece of cheesecake from seemingly nowhere and takes a bite out of it, moaning.

"Masky, fuck you."

KageKao:

"I don't get why the other pastas keep calling me a 'homo', (Y/N)."

"It's because you're dating a guy, Kage." You sighed, Kage wasn't completely fluent in English quite yet. He can't help it, don't be angry. You reminded yourself.

"But I'm actually a girl under this mask." He said seriously.

"You have quite a visible adam's apple and I've seen you with your pants down."

"That was merely a disguise to trick you into dating. I've known you were into guys since I first met you and I thought you'd be more attractive to me if I appeared as one."

"Oh yeah? How'd you disguise what's in your pants then?"

"I attached a dil-"

"SCREW OFF FOR FUCK'S SAKE ALREADY!"

Laughing Jack:

"I love you, I do, but I don't think I'm homosexual. I think I might just be straight." L.J. suddenly said as you two were watching television.

"What do you mean, can you elaborate?"

"Well, you see, I saw this super hot chick at the carnival earlier and..."

"And so now you think you aren't gay," you questioned. "But do I still turn you on?"

"A lot." You burst out laughing. "What?"

"Oh, Jack! You're bisexual!"

"What does that mean?"

"It means you're into both males and females." You giggled. "But you're not allowed to check out other people ever again. Just because I have balls doesn't mean I don't have feelings."

Sonic.Exe:

"Hey, Sonic~" Sally.exe chimed in, walking through the doorway. "You're looking nice today.~"

"I'm always looking nice, Sally." Sonic was currently attending a birthday party for one of his buddy pastas, though he didn't think Sally was invited. However, she was attractive to him.

"I can't argue that. Though I heard that you're taken nowadays, is that right?"

"Yeah, he's pretty cool."

"He? So you're gay?" Sonic nodded then proceeded to chug down the rest of his whiskey.

"I don't know, probably."

"Why don't we go to my place and provide evidence against that?" She winked. Sonic opened his mouth to agree, but wouldn't that hurt you? Having a fling with someone else- a girl no less. If he's in love with you, doesn't that show that he's homosexual?

Sonic laughed, "go fuck yourself. I know you have plenty of dildos to do so."

Homicidal Liu:

Liu sat in a barstool at the counter that connected to your kitchen as he watched you make dinner. "Psst. Liu."

"What is it, Sully?" Liu said a bit irritated. Sully had been trying to convince Liu to leave you all day.

"There's no way we're gay. Do you even feel any sexual appeal to him? He's a guy!"

"I know he's a guy, Sully, and that guy is our boyfriend."

"My point is that, he's the first guy we've dated. There's no way we're homosexual just because of one fling." Sully was getting more and more persistent.

"This isn't a fling! I'm serious!" You went to a cabinet across the room and stood on the tip of your toes to be able to reach an ingredient you needed. In Liu and Sally, this caused a not-so-pretty thing for them to happen within their clothing.

"Nevermind, you're right."

Zalgo:

"Why is it that some of the other humans look at us weirdly when we show public displays of affection?" Your boyfriend curiously asked.

"Well, it's because some of them don't agree with us."

"Do they think you're too handsome to be with me?" You laughed.

"No, not at all. It's because some people are known as 'homophobes' and they don't support homosexuals."

"Are we homosexuals?" He tilted his head.

"Since we're a guy dating another guy couple, yes."

"The lord of the underworld has no gender. "

Dark Link:

Currently, you were in a shopping district to quickly pick up a few gifts for the upcoming holiday. It wasn't very crowded that day since it had been raining all day, however, it had let up to where you could actually seen the other people and store signs. Unfortunately for you, you spotted Dark Link surrounded by a group of girls. Holding your umbrella tightly, you went over and tapped him on the shoulder.

"What the hell, Dark?" He looked shocked to see you.

"Ohh, is this a friend of yours?~ He's petty cute.~" A girl with black hair rubbed her hand over your chest.

"No. He's my boyfriend." Dark sighed.

"I thought you were over flirting aimlessly?!" You asked annoyed.

"Waiit. So like, you're gay?" A brunette with blonde streaks through her hair questioned, making Dark nod. "Eeww."

"Ew?" He asked in return.

"God's against that."

"See you in hell then, sweetie, because he's also against whores." Dark burst out laughing at your remark and kissed you, which made the other girls leave as you two had a conversation over his flirting habits.

Radioface:

"(Y/N)!" Radio suddenly yelled whilst you were sleeping.

"Whaat?"

"I'm sorry, but I'm not gay." Immediately, you could feel the tears threatening to spill.

"What?"

"Yeah, it turns out I'm bisexual. I learned about it from L.J. earlier."

"Fuck off." With that, you slumped back into your covers.