(No, I'm not going any smut in here and I'm also doing female pronouns, but you're welcome to change them if you wish... Sorry :))

My breathing accelerated as I read the name on the piece of paper. Rereading it just to make sure I was seeing this correctly.

"Toby..."  I muttered, jumping when Splendor took the paper from my hand.

"Ah! The finest proxy!" He chirps, causing Masky to growl under his breath while glaring at the twitching boy.

Hoodie, Kate The Chaser, Nemesis, and Rouge simply rolled their eyes towards him as they crossed their arms. It's normal to see Masky upset because Toby is Slender's right hand-man instead of him.

I tensed up when Toby approached next to my side, smirking down at me out of the corner of his brown eyes. He wasn't wearing his mouth guard or his goggles so I saw everything. He's about, what? 5'9? I don't know, all I know is he's taller than me.

"Alright, you two can stop eyeing each other and get in the closet, love birds~" Splendor giggles, making me blush out of embarrassment. Was I staring? I know Toby was for sure... Ugh! Stupid hormones.

Walking into the empty closet, I felt my legs tremble beneath me before my whole body began to shake. Picking up my pace, I made my way into the closet without looking like a fool in front of everyone, and Toby who was walking behind me, which worsened everything as I felt his eyes on me.

The twitching male stood next to me with his hands in his pockets, staring straight ahead at Spendor. "Have fun you two! But not too much fun~"

"SPLENDOR! YOU'RE SPENDING WAY TOO MUCH TIME AROUND OFFENDER!"

Holding in a chuckle at Slenderman's comment, I heard Toby hum in delight from the darkness as Splendor shuts the door, locking it. Standing in the dark, I tapped my fingers on my legs, not knowing what to do as the air around us became tense.

I don't wanna just start talking to him, that'll make everything awkward! Groaning, I ran my hands over my face before taking a set on the ground, crossing my legs in the process. Humming a small melody once I felt comfortable, I rested my elbows on my legs, placing my chin in the palm of my hand.

I didn't know where Toby was, but I realized he was standing up because of his ticking. Hearing a pop echo in the dark, I thought he cracked his neck so I ignored the sound.

"Hey, (Y/n)..." Turning my head in his direction, I screamed when I saw a hatchet flying towards me. Fortunately, it hit the wall above my head, but still!

"Toby! What the hell?" I growled, taking his hatchet out of his hands.

"What? It was funny. Can't I scare my friends at times?" He chuckles, his voice was lower to the ground, letting me know he was sitting.

"That doesn't give you a reason to almost kill me! Can you even see in here? Because I know I can't!" I glared at the proxy, seeing a faded outline of him not that far from me. He just shakes his head, leaning against the wall with his hands behind his head.

"Whatever you say, (Y-Y/n)." Toby stutters, sighing deeply, making me think he's going to take a nap.

"What's it like?" I mumbled, twirling his hatchet in my hands.

"What's what like?" He hums, tilting his head towards me. "Being a proxy? It's hard but nice at times. Then you got M-Masky who you wanna kick your foot up his ass cause he won't leave you the fuck alone. Geez... At least the others mind their own business."

I smiled, imagining the thought of Toby and Masky. 

"Yeah, he can be annoying at times. He can be an asshole whenever he wants." I shrugged, handing Toby back his weapon. Seeing that my eyes had adapted well to the darkness,  I watched as Toby eyed his weapon before glancing back up at me.

"I thought you were gonna keep it." He chuckles, joking around with me before it got removed from my hand.

"I would like to, but no, you need it." I smiled, jumping as the closet door swung open, revealing a smiling BEN.

"Damn, I expected to see something other than Toby trying to kill (Y/n)." The gamer boy sighed, walking away from us.

"I wasn't trying to kill her? If I want to, I-I would have done so a while ago." Toby grunts, getting off the ground before lending me a hand.

"Thank you, Toby." Grabbing his hand, I give him a small smile before we went our ways for the night. Turning to go to my room, I felt a firm grip on my arm.

"(Y/n)? I was wondering if you wanted to hang out l-later?" Toby coughed, rubbing the back of his neck.

A blush crept onto my face as I smiled at him, "I would love to. Now go on your mission before Masky yells at you." I chuckled, causing Toby to roll his eyes at the mention of Masky's name.

"See you tonight, sillyhead."