Aries: Jeff the killer
(Grey: he did it with a bloody knife)

Capricorn: Puppeteer

Scorpio: Kagekao

Pisces: Sally

Cancer: Nina the killer

Leo: Ben drowned

Libra: Slenderman

Aquarius: Eyeless jack
(Grey: you guys made a Jack-o'lantern
Get it cause the name,no....ok....umm *hides in the hoodie and cries*)

Virgo: Ticci Toby
(Grey: you made a flaming Jack-o'lantern)

Gemini: Lost silver

Sagittarius: Laughing jack

Taurus: Hoodie