Aries: Jeff the killer

Capricorn: Ticci Toby
(I hope he didn't burn the kitchen)

Scorpio: Homicidal liu

Pisces: slenderman

Cancer: tenderman

Leo: Ben drowned

Libra: Bloody painter

Aquarius: judge angles

Virgo: Glitchy red

Gemini: lost silver

Taurus: Laughing jack

Sagittarius: Zero