Aries: Jeff the killer

Capricorn: Ticci Toby

Scorpio: Hoodie

Pieces: Masky

Cancer: slenderman

Leo: sexual offenderman
[I feel terrible for you]

Libra: Homicidal liu

Aquarius: Glitchy Red

Virgo: laughing jack

Gemini: Eyeless jack

Sagittarius: Ben drowned

Taurus: Jason the toy maker

[This was actually ment to be published on valentine's Day! I'm so sorry! Please forgive me. . . ]
[I don't deserve forgiveness do I?]