[Grey: sorry for the long tittle,enjoy!]

Actual tittle: who always borrows your things and never returned it back to you?

Aries: Dr.Smiley

Capricorn: Bloody painter

Scorpio: Ticci Toby

Pisces: Nina the killer

Cancer: Masky

Leo: puppeteer

Libra: Judge angles

Aquarius: Eyeless jack

Virgo: Hoodie

Gemini: Jeff the killer

Sagittarius: Zero

Taurus: Laughing jack