My first preference!
Idea credit to oblivious80s

Bill: Bill is the type to show up at your house with a guitar and sing you a really cheesy song on your doorstep. The chords are off and the lyrics are silly, but it's obviously totally adorable.

Then usually you two will go inside and watch movies until you fall asleep in his arms.
Although it's usually him falling asleep in yours. <3

Ted: Ted goes over to your house and takes you to some food trucks so you can eat on the go. If it's a really nice day and he has extra money, he'll take you to Waterloo and hug you close to him on waterslides.

If it's not nice enough for that, you two stroll through San Dimas and pet every dog you see.

Because who can be sad when you have dogs and Ted 'Theodore Logan?

Hope you guys liked it! If you have any requests or ideas for preferences, please let me know! :D
Be Excellent to each other and Party on dudes! \m/