cutiepiefangirl_ Asked me this question.

Answer:
there are pros and cons of both skinny Steve and muscular Steve.

skinny Steve
pros
~Small=cute
~Determined to be in the army, no matter what his size
~really REALLY tries hard, even when climbing nets!
cons
~If dancing,there might be glanced turned your way... I mean, dancing with a skinny boy from Brooklyn?
~Small
~you could probably break his bones by touching him

muscular Steve
pros
~muscular
~Captain America
~tall
~easier to dance with
cons
~he's still the skinny kid from Brooklyn, if you think about it.
~The press would be asking him questions, so it would be hard to dance with him

Overall, I would say buffer Steve mainly because he's easier to dance with and he's more army material. hmm.... but the skinny one was the one I fell in love with. I guess there really is no possible answer to this one.

He is the same Stevie, after all...