Enis: (he's the top picture)

Edith:

(Both Enis and Edith have those black markings on the side of their face)

Molten

Lefty

Bryan:

Circus baby:

Ballora:

Funtime Chica:

Orville elephant:

Rockstar Freddy:

Rockstar Chica:

Neddbear:

Music Man:

Funtime Freddy:

Rockstar Bonnie:

Mr. Hippo:

Pigpatch:

Funtime Foxy:

Happy Frog:

El Chip:

Rockstar Foxy:

This is what everyone in the story looks like.

Everyone's ages:
Bryan: 26
Enis: 16
Edith: 16
Circus Baby: 13
Ballora: 42
Funtime Chica: 19
Orville Elephant: 21
Rockstar Freddy: 14
Rockstar Chica: 27
Neddbear: 29
Music Man: 15
Funtime Freddy: 34
Rockstar Foxy: 21
Mr. Hippo: 43
Pigpatch: 31
Funtime Foxy: 34
Happy Frog: 23
El Chip: 45
Lefty: 17
Molten: 17

Youngest to oldest:

Circus Baby, Rockstar Freddy, Music Man, Edith and Enis, Lefty and Molten, Funtime Chica, Rockstar Foxy and Orville Elephant, Bryan, Happy Frog, Rockstar Chica, Neddbear, Pigpatch, Funtime Freddy, Funtime Foxy, Ballora, El Chip.