Aries: Jeff the Killer

Taurus: Nina the Killer

Gemini: Clockwork

Cancer: Sally

Leo: Eyeless Jack

Virgo: Slenderman

Libra: Ticci Toby

Scorpio: Jane the Killer

Sagittarius: Hoodie

Capricorn: Ben Drowned

Aquarius: Masky

Pisces: Homicidal Liu