(Thank you to Bubbles070506 for this idea! At least I think it was you? If you gave me this idea and I didn't tag you then please comment or something to let me know!)

Sarah was happily spinning around her room, jumping up and down as she brushed out her hair. "I'm going on a dateeeeee! Like a real one this time!"
"What are you gonna do on your date?" Jonathan asked, pulling Cara down onto his lap again so he could continue braiding her hair.
"I'm not sure yet actually, he didn't really specify." Sarah said, shrugging. "But it's gonna be awesome! He said we're probably gonna go get food and hang out! And you wanna know the best part?"
"Mhm."
"We'll actually be one on one! Not at school or anything! I'm so excited! It's gonna be so awesome!" She exclaimed, twirling around again, her hair getting in her face.
Cara grinned happily at her older sister. "Das so cool! When do I get to meet him?"
"Soon, Caz, I promise you'll meet him soon." Sarah said, ruffling her sister's hair much to Jonathan's disliking.
"It was smooth already! Now I gotta do it over again!" He protested, grabbing the small pink comb next to Cara, parting her hair again.
"Jonny, why're you whining again?" Mitchell asked, one of his eyes done with some intense drag queen-like makeup.
"Holy shit." Jonathan and Sarah both said in sync, staring at him.
"Howy sheet!" Cara said, making grabby hands at her brother. "Is shiny!"
"Yeah it is! And you both, don't curse in front of the little kid, okay? She's learning from you two." He said, rolling his eyes a little, his boyfriend walking over.
"Hold up, when did Spencer get here?" Sarah asked, hugging him tightly.
"Um, I've been here for the past two hours." Spencer said, laughing a little as he wrapped his arm around Mitchell's shoulders, holding him close. "Did you just notice me?"
Sarah nodded, smiling a little at her brother's boyfriend. "Yeah, also are you doing makeup right now?"
"Yep, tonight is a stay in date night, obviously cause I can't go out in this getup, I'm gonna get a lot of weird looks from a lot of people." Mitchell said, resting his head on Spencer's shoulder, his eyes closing for a second as he hummed a little softly.
Sarah smiled at her brother and his boyfriend before gasping excitedly. "Mitch, Spence, what if we all went on a double date? That would be awesome!"
Spencer looked nervously at the shorter boy next to him. "No, it's okay...I know you're excited for you and him to go on this, and you should! So go have fun!"
Sarah frowned a bit, crossing her arms over her chest. "But it'd be fun..." she said, twirling around the room again, going in front of the mirror to fix her hair.
"You two have fun, okay? We'll be here if you need anything." Mitchell said before grabbing Spencer's hand, leading him out of his sister's room and back into his own.
"Huh...wonder what got into those two..." Sarah said, jumping as the doorbell rang, her brother and his boyfriend shouting a curse word at the same time. "See what I mean?"
Jonathan nodded, picking Cara up so he could go answer the door. "I don't know, maybe they're just having a weird day."

"HEY SARAH! YOUR BOYFRIEND IS HERE!" Karamo called. "Would you like to come in for a bit? She's probably just getting herself ready and everything."
"Yeah, she's super excited!" Tan said, smiling widely as he spotted Sarah, grabbing her hands as he bounced up and down a little. "There you are! Have fun okay? And when you get home I want all the details."
Sarah nodded, laughing as she hugged Tan. "I promise to tell you everything, don't you worry."
"We're gonna need all the tea." Karamo said, hugging her also, frowning a little as he saw Jordan roll his eyes at then. "Anyway, go have fun with your man!"
"Oh my gosh, you guys need to shush." She said, rolling her eyes also, still grinning. "Bye, Jonny, bye, Cara, be good okay?"
"WAIT!" Cara shrieked, climbing out of Jonathan's arms, running over to Jordan, holding her arms up to him. "Hug?"
Jordan looked down at her, raising his eyebrows. "Seriously? Um, I gotta go, maybe next time, kid." He said, grabbing Sarah's hand, pulling her outside, his arm instantly going around her waist.
"Don't be home too late!" Jonathan called.
"I won't!" Sarah called back. "Oh, and tell Mitch and Spence bye for me okay?"
"We will, love you." Antoni said.
"Love you too!"
Jordan rolled his eyes a bit, leading Sarah down the stairwell. "Your family is really overprotective, do they let you have any fun?" He asked almost in an annoyed tone.
"Yep! We have lots of fun! Why do you ask?"
"Cause you hardly answer my texts, and I thought they were taking your phone."
"No, I just put it away to spend time with them."
"Oh, okay, I get it that they're more important, that's okay."
Sarah sighed, feeling her anxiety build up, knowing they would have to have this talk again. She wished that Jordan would just for once not have something to comment about her family, and they could just gave a normal date.

"How's the makeup coming?" Bobby asked through the bedroom door, knocking softly on it.
"Just um...finishing up my eyeliner!" Mitchell called back before gasping a little, laughter coming from inside his room.
"Don't tell me they're making out right now." Karamo said. "Cause I don't wanna know."
"Shut uuuup!" Mitchell exclaimed, his boyfriend pulling him closer to the bed he was sitting on, getting the shorter boy to sit on his lap. "What're you doing, babe?"
"Just lookin." Spencer said, gently cupping his boyfriend's face in his hands, kissing him. "You're so pretty."
Mitchell blushed, wrapping his arms around Spencer's neck. "You're pretty too y'know...also can I ask you something?"
"Go for it."
"Do...do you mind that I do makeup like this? And sometimes dress more girly?" Mitchell asked, frowning a bit as he looked down.
"I don't mind at all, baby, you could wear whatever you want, do makeup like this, or you could wear some basketball shorts and a random shirt makeup free." Spencer replied, making his boyfriend look at him. "I love you, not what you wear or your makeup, even though I do like what you pick, but I fell in love with you."
"Spencer, I love you to death, but if you make me cry and mess up my makeup I will break your ribs." Mitchell said, giggling as he leaned in to kiss his boyfriend, smiling as Spencer kissed him back, his hands moving down to the smaller boy's sides.
"Hey, guys, I was wondering if you wanted to-woah, okay bad timing." Antoni said, who had just opened the door and was now standing in the doorway, not knowing what to do now.
"Ant, really, right now?" Mitchell asked, looking back at his boyfriend.
"It's okay, Mitchy, what's up, Antoni?" Spencer asked, helping Mitch stand back up, wrapping both of his arms around his waist, resting his chin on his shoulder.
"Did you guys wanna go get food or something? Or do you want us to go pick something up?" Antoni asked, gesturing to the other four guys on the couch.
"Yeah, food sounds great!" Mitchell said, looking over at Spencer. "Can I wear your Yankees hoodie? You can wear one of my shirts if you need it."
Spencer smiled, unwrapping his arms from around Mitchell, slipping his hoodie off, handing it to his boyfriend. "You can keep it, you're always asking to wear it."
"It smells like you..." the shorter mumbled softly, holding the hoodie close.
"I'm right here y'know, also what do I smell like?"
"Um...hair gel, those lavender dryer sheets your mom uses, and just...you I guess." Mitchell replied, laughing a little as he spoke. "What about me?"
"Citrus shampoo, whatever kind of detergent you use here, and that perfume I got you from Walgreens...you smell pretty."

"I hate to end this lovely little chat, but I'm about to go puke." Karamo said, getting a slap in the arm from Tan.
"Oh shush, let them be cute." He said, grinning up at the younger two boys.
"I ship it!" Jonathan shouted.
"We're already dating!" Mitchell shouted back.
"I still ship it!"
The two rolled their eyes, following Antoni into the kitchen, sitting down at the table to watch what he was doing. "I'm just making nachos, you two, is that okay? No one is lactose intolerant right?"
"Nope, we're good." Spencer said. "Oh, did Sarah leave already?"
"Yep, she left a few minutes ago, she wanted to tell ya'll bye." Bobby said, coming into the kitchen to join in the conversation.
"Oh okay." Mitchell said unenthusiastically.
"What's wrong?" Antoni asked, leaning against the kitchen counter a bit. "I can see something's bothering you."
"Well, I know we don't do straight here, but I'll tell you that way." Spencer said, spotting Cara walking over. "He's a pain in the a-s-s."
"Who we talkin bout?" Cara piped up, making grabby hands at Spencer, her face brightening as he picked her up, holding her on his lap. "Also Jordy's mean..."
"Why is Jordan mean, honey? What happened?" Bobby asked worriedly.
"I wanted to hug him, and he didn't wanna hug me." Cara said, messing with her skirt. "Spencewr always gives me hugs."
"And you're gonna get them all the time, princess." Spencer said, hugging the little girl tightly.
"Yeah, like Spence said, Jordan is a pain in the ass...he makes fun of me for every little thing." Mitchell added. "My makeup, my clothes, being gay, having a boyfriend, living with a freak show family...the fact you guys aren't my real parents."
Karamo, Jonathan, and Tan had come over, hearing Mitchell spill everything out, his voice cracking as the memories of every incident with Jordan flooding back into his mind.
"He makes fun off you for all that? Does Sarah know?" Tan asked, looking at the rest of the Fab 5, trying to figure out what to do.
Mitchell shook his head. "I didn't wanna ruin him for her...I wanted her to be happy, I thought I could tell her if things got worse..."
"Mitch, things are already terrible, this isn't okay." Jonathan said, frowning as he spoke. "This has been going on since he and Sarah started dating?"
"No, since I started going to school and he was there."
"Holy shit." The five guys said at the same time, looking at each other.
"Anybody got a plan?" Bobby asked, seeing the other men shrug.
"Well, when those two get back we're having a talk. Ant, you and Mitchell and Spencer should go talk to Sarah, and the rest of us can handle that bitch." Karamo replied, and he would have continued the conversation if the door hadn't been flung open.

Sarah was standing in the doorway, tears covering her face, her whole body shaking. "He's coming..." she said as Tan yanked her into the house, holding her close.
"Hold the kid someone." Spencer said, handing Cara off to Karamo, he and Mitchell going outside.
The Fab 5 and Sarah heard the two younger boys yelling at who they guesses was Jordan, profanities spilling out of their mouths. Mitchell was suddenly seen kicking Jordan in the stomach, sending him back down the stairs, he and his boyfriend running back into the house, shutting and locking the door.
"Good job, babe." Spencer said, kissing Mitchell's cheek, wrapping his arms around his waist.
"Thanks, babe." The shorter boy said before rushing over to his sister. "Are you okay?"
"Do I look okay?" She asked, wiping her red eyes.
"What happened, angel? Did he hurt you?" Antoni asked, holding her close.
"N-no, he yelled at me, said he hated me and my freak family, and said he was embarrassed to be seen with me." Sarah said, sobbing as she spoke. "A-and I punched him and ran."
"That's my girl." Tan muttered, rubbing her back.
"We're proud of you, Sarah, did you break up with him?" Karamo asked, giving her a small smile.
"Y-yeah, well we both yelled f-fuck you at each other, and I said I was done with him, he said the same to me...then I punched him and he chased me..." She replied, pulling her knees up to her chest. "It reminded me of my biological dad..."
Mitchell bit his lower lip, looking down at the floor. They both hadn't talked about him in a long time, and had been happy without it being referenced. Whenever it was brought up they usually shut down, not wanting to talk about it at all.
"Oh honey..." Jonathan said, hugging Sarah tightly. "We wouldn't let him hurt you, or yell at you if we were there."
"I'm gonna go yell at him about this..." Bobby said, crossing his arms over his chest.
"This is why we don't date dicks, sweetpea, they all suck and think only about themselves." Karamo said, kissing the top of Sarah's head. "Maybe try girls?"
Sarah laughed, shaking her head. "I'm pretty sure I'm straight, but I'll wait a while to date again, I sure as hell don't want another Jordan."
"Straight? In this house? I can't believe it." Jonathan said dramatically.
"Oh shush." Sarah said, rolling her eyes. "Thanks for being here for me...also Mitch? Spence? Can I crash your date and hang with you both? Well, technically all of you?"
"Of course! I'd be happy to have you crash with us!" Spencer said, hugging Sarah. "You can pick the movie, and I got the popcorn!"
"I swear ya'll are the best..."

(This is super late and probably had a ton of typos but yeah! Hope this was okay!)