Blaine was grateful that Puck understood why he didn't say anything, and said

"Even Kurt knew, I had to make sure he didn't say anything. It's in her best interest if she didn't know, and his best interest too. Rachel would have freaked out and bailed you know as well as I do that Rachel spent far too long going along with Finn's mind games of only being interested in her when he lost her attention. And when I was at Dalton, I had a suspicion that Sebastian may have had feelings for Rachel but was hiding them from everyone. I just want them both happy, even if it meant them being together." Puck understood and he said

"After Rachel lost her parents and started living with me, my mum and sister and Jake when he visits, she was withdrawn, and when she laughed and smiled in class that day she told me about the NYADA group chat, it was a breath of fresh air, something that me and my family haven't heard or seen in a long time." Blaine sighed and I said

"I know."

As Sebastian and Rachel walked outside, Sebastian looked at Rachel and said

"So Broadwaybabi, if I guessed right on your name would you tell me?" Rachel was nervous because she didn't know how Sebastian would react, and she said

"Maybe." Sebastian raised an eyebrow at her and said

"Maybe? How about we play 20 questions?" Rachel looked at him and said

"How about 10?" Sebastian was just grateful that he gets to talk to her and said

"I'll what I can get." Sebastian thought about it and said

"You do actually go to McKinley, and you didn't lie to me about that." Rachel softly giggled and said

"Of course." Sebastian gave a small smile and said

"Just checking, otherwise I would have transferred to McKinley from Dalton for nothing, and you never know with internet and everything." Rachel was shocked to learn that Sebastian transferred for her and not actually knowing that it is her. Sebastian squeezed Rachel's hand and said

"My next question, Were you disappointed to find out that I was fauvetteLAX24? and please be honest." Rachel gave him a smile and said

"Surprisingly no." Sebastian was surprised by her answer, and said

"Did you vote for me to be Homecoming King?" Rachel looked at him and said

"Surprisingly yes." Sebastian looked at her surprised and said

"Really?" Rachel nodded her head and Sebastian then said

"I got it. If given the choice would you go for a Rice Cake or a burger?" Rachel screwed her nose up and said

"Neither because I'm Vegan." Sebastian looked at her shocked and said

"You're Vegan? So am I." Rachel looked at him shocked and Sebastian continued

"We are more alike than we think." Sebastian stared into her eyes and said

"You would think I know you by your eyes, which are beautiful by the way."

Rachel blushed under her mask, especially when Sebastian lifted his hands to her mask to take it off, when all of a sudden her phone beeped, and she ran away from Sebastian. As she ran she didn't know her star of David necklace came undone at the back and fell off.

Puck saw Rachel run, and signaled for Brittany, Blaine and Kurt to follow her. When they reached Rachel, Puck put a comforting hand on her shoulder as they reached his car. It will be okay. Rachel was on the verge of tears, she couldn't believe her prince Charming was none other Sebastian Smythe.

Sebastian was confused when Rachel ran off. He was walking back inside when he saw her necklace on the ground. As he picked it up Thad and Hunter walked over to him, and Thad said

"How did your Juliet, did you at least find out who your BroadwayBabi is?" Sebastian shook his head as he stood up and said

"It went well, before she ran off after her phone bleeped, and no I didn't find out who she is. I was about to take off her mask, but i didn't." Hunter sighed and said

"That sucks." Before Hunter could continue, Sebastian smiled at them both and said

"But I know how we could find her." Thad and Hunter looked at each other and then at Sebastian and said

"How?" Sebastian showed them the Necklace he picked up and said

"With this. Whoever she is, she would be looking for this." As Thad stared at the necklace, he said

"Now it's more like Cinderella." But as Thad stared at the necklace in Sebastian's hand, he had now realised where he had heard her voice before when he heard her speak to his best friend, and Thad knew who owned that necklace, he just prayed she wasn't using his best friend. Thad gulped and said

"I have to go. I have to check on something." Thad turned around and messaged Blaine to meet at the Lima Bean.

When Thad arrived at the coffee shop, he waited a little for Blaine to turn up. He looked up when the door opened and Blaine had walked in. Blaine sat across from him, and Thad immediately spoke

"It's Rachel isn't it." Blaine was confused and said

"I have no idea what you're talking about Harwood." Thad looked at him and said

"Yes you do. Rachel is Sebastian's BroadwayBabi. I know you know Blaine." Blaine looked down and then at Thad and said

"Of course I do." Thad stood up to go leave and said

"When were you going to tell me Anderson?" Blaine stood up and stood behind Thad and said

"Around the same time you and Clarington were going to me that Sebastian is Rachel's FauvetteLAX24, I figured it out two days ago Harwood, it doesn't take a genius to work out why the former captain of the warblers and Dalton Lacrosse team just all of a sudden appeared at Mckinley. now you and Clarington had reasons with Santana and Quinn being at McKinley, but Smythe on the other not so much. So when were you going to tell me about Smythe?" Thad stopped his tracks and then turned to sit back down with Blaine sat across from him

"Touche." Thad sighed at Blaine and said

"Why didn't tell her when you found out?" Blaine sighed and said

"Because." Thad looked at him confused and curious and said

"Because why Anderson?" Blaine looked at him and said

"It's in her best interest that she didn't know, same with Sebastian. If i tell you, you'll understand why too and agree with me that it is."