( credits to theoutsiders-oneshots on tumblr 💛 )

It wasn't the first time Tim had shown up at you and Dallas' small one-room apartment because he needed a place to spend the night and no other place was available. And it probably wouldn't be the last time either.

The apartment was more so for one person living there maybe two if you were pushing it so three people were not very comfortable. Dallas and you would sleep in your bed together and Tim would sleep on the floor with a small spare mattress that somehow managed to fit under your bed.

There was one small bathroom and the rest of the house was just one room. No walls separated the bedroom from the kitchen and you didn't have a dining room. That's all you could afford at the moment. Sure it was small but it was cheap.

If Tim had come over at another time it would have been fine but Dally and you were going at it when he knocked meaning you had to stop having sex. You both let out annoyed sighs. You cover yourself with your blanket and Dallas quickly puts on a pair of boxers to go answer the door.

His hard-on was disappearing due to the interruption and you were already half as horny as you were before the knock on the door. You knew it would be Tim. No one else would be at your door at this time of night unless the two of you were too loud and this time you were being quiet.

Dally hid his lower body behind the door when he opened it slightly to see who It was.

"I swear you have the worst timing, Tim. Hold on a sec." He closes the door and turns to you. "Put some clothes on Y/n, Tim's here."

You sigh.

"Of course he is." You put on underwear, a t-shirt that was too big for you and short shorts.

When you're finished and have sat down on the bed again Dallas opens the door and Tim walks in, immediately heading for the mattress under the bed. Dally closes and locks the door, heading over to your shared bed again.

Tim gives you a look over and then looks back at Dally.

"Oh. That's why you said I have the worst timing. You two were going at it like bunnies again."

"At least I actually get some." Dallas counters with a smirk.

"Well, at least I've actually pleased the women I've been with."

"No, I can attest that Dal has definitely given me pleasure before." You butt in.

Dallas sits down beside you on the bed, slinging an arm around your shoulder.

"If you had met me before you met Dally you would have been mine, not his. I could have shown you a lot more pleasure than him." Tim states.

"Well, she's mine," Dallas says possessively. "I'm the one who had my cock inside Y/n not even ten minutes ago."

"Dallas!" You slap his chest, embarrassed.

Tim laughs at your reaction.

"Fair enough." He says as he puts a blanket on the mattress.

It already had a mattress cover on it since Tim came over often.

"I'm going to bed."

"Okay. Goodnight, Tim." You say.

Tim nods get on the mattress and takes off his shirt.

"Let's go to bed too, babe." Dally made sure to accentuate the word babe to rub it in Tim's face.

He turns off the lamp beside your bed and you both crawl under the covers and start spooning with you being the little spoon. You were facing the part of the bed that didn't face the wall and instead faced Tim. Tim faced away from your bed, looking at the opposite wall.

It was quiet for about half an hour. Still, you couldn't fall asleep. Sex usually made you feel more awake, especially when you didn't finish. The same went for Dallas, which was why he was tracing patterns into your forearm with his thumb. Tim was breathing steadily which meant he had fallen asleep.

Dally's hand moved down from your forearm to your hip, you thought nothing of it at first but when he unbuttoned your shorts and started unzipping them you knew he didn't have innocent intentions.

"Babe we can't. Not while he's here." You whisper-shout, a blush forming on your face.

"Yeah, we can. You'll just have to be quiet, if you can that is." He replied as he groped your boobs through your tank top.

"What if he wakes up?"

"Pretend to be asleep."

You bite your lip, feeling a little unsure.

"Fine..." You give in.

He slides off your shorts and panties and takes off his boxers.

"Take off your shirt and bra." He orders.

"But-"

"I said take it off, Y/n."

Blushing you take it off. Having Dallas order you around really turned you on, you couldn't help but obey.

Dally played with your clit as he left hickeys on your neck. Both of you were still in a spooning position; you assumed that was how you would have sex. The position was comfortable but you were facing Tim which was quite embarrassing.

"Can we switch positions?" You ask.

He stops leaving hickeys on your neck but continues to play with your clit.

"Why?"

"I'm facing Tim, it's awkward." You explain.

"No, we are staying in this position. I want you to know that you're mine. You'll know your mine because I'll be the one with my cock buried deep inside of you."

You knew arguing would be useless and probably make things worse so you didn't say anymore. Besides he was turning you on too much for you to care.

His hard-on was pressed against your ass; you wanted it inside of you. As if Dally could read your mind he started putting just the tip in to tease you.

"That's what it would be like if Tim was fucking you." He thrusted fully into you and you gasped. "This is what it's like with me fucking you."

He set a rough and fast pace which made the bed shake and creak. You had to bite your lip to keep from moaning and even that didn't completely help so you grabbed a pillow and covered your mouth with it so you could moan and it be muffled.

"D-Dally we have to be quiet or he'll wake up."

"Let him wake up and see how good I fuck my little whore. I want him to see that he can't have you but I can."

"I'm sure he already knows that Dallas-" You cut yourself off with a moan. "He'll tell the gang and Two-bit will never let me live this down."

"You're always thinking about other guys, even while I'm fucking you. You really are a whore. I'm going to be generous and give you another chance, Y/n. Say my name and forget about the world for a second, forget about our surroundings. Pretend that it's just me and you right now." Dally groans.

"I don't know if I can..."

"Do it." He slaps your ass hard causing you to moan loudly.

You look over at Tim who still seemed to be sleeping.

"I told you to forget about our surroundings. Obey me." Dallas slaps your ass again.

"I'm sorry. I will."

"Moan my name then. Be loud."

He thrusts into you hard and you moan his name quietly, you didn't want Tim waking up.

"Louder or I won't let you orgasm." He smirks.

"Dallas!" You moan louder this time.

You moaned a little too loud as Tim moved a little in his sleep. You cover your mouth with the pillow again.

"That's more like it." He then starts going at an unbelievably fast pace.

You feel yourself building up quickly. Dallas starts leaving hickeys on your neck again and you orgasm. You moan Dally's name without being told to. Your body shakes from the powerful orgasm and you can't help but close your eyes, then you go limp.

Dally continues to pound into you until he cums. It wasn't very long after so the oversensitivity didn't cause you to orgasm twice.

He pulls roughly on your hair making your head go back.

"No one can fuck you like I do. Don't you ever forget that." Dallas says and then pulls out of you.

You lay on your stomach on the bed, trying to recover from the orgasm. Dally lights a cigarette and starts puffing away.

"We aren't supposed to smoke in here." You breathe out.

"I don't care."

You sit up and lean into him, he slings an arm around your waist so he can hold you close. It didn't take long for you to fall asleep in his arms. After he finished the cigarette he noticed you had fallen asleep. Dallas laid you down on the bed and kissed your forehead.

"Goodnight, Y/n. I love you."

-

When you woke up Tim was drinking coffee on the mattress and Dallas was cuddling with you. Luckily the blanket was covering both of you, neither of you had put your clothes on after having sex.

You look over at Dallas, he was awake and it seemed like he had been talking with Tim. Neither of them had realised you were awake yet so you closed your eyes and pretended to be asleep.

"I think I'm going to marry her." Dallas paused. "I don't want to see her with another guy, I love her too much."

"Yeah I can tell. I heard you guys a little last night." Tim replied.

Dally chuckled. You started blushing but your face was buried in Dallas' neck so nobody noticed.

"Do you know how many complaints we've gotten for the noise? It's impressive."

By now your face was as red as a stop sign. Why did he have to be telling his best friend all of this? You did sort of do the same thing so you couldn't really blame him but it was embarrassing.

You felt Dally poke your cheek.

"You awake?" He asks.

"Yes..." You say as you slowly open your eyes.

"How was your sleep?"

Your blush was calming down a bit.

"Really good. How was yours, babe?"

"Same as yours." He winked at you.

So much for your blush calming down.

"Well I'll be going." Tim said as he started walking to the door. "Bye."

After he left you sat up, making sure the blanket was covering your chest.

"I love you." You say to Dallas as you gave him a good morning kiss.

"I love you too." He smiled and kissed you again.