Oh...oh my gosh! I am so excited to rant on her! I did like her but there's just so much to write about! So first off she's part of a prophecy, which is always a sin.

 Also since she didn't believe Goosefeaher that's also a sin.

 So he also tells her to not visit Oakheart, but what does she do? THE COMPLETE OPPOSITE. because of that she has kits, gives them away to be deputy and quote 'save the clan', one of the kits die, and the other two don't even know about their mother until Firestar goes and ruins that! 

She didn't even live for very long! Like for the first arc unlike Firestar who lived forever! Also, she ended up chasing Thistleclaw out of StarClan to the Dark Forest because she didn't like him! I wonder what Snowfur thinks of Bluestar now.

 Also, she likes Oakheart in the living world right? Well, she treats him like garbage in StarClan from what I could see. She also had that whole 'oh all of my family died' cliché. And too top it all off she saves Firestar!!! FIRESTAR!! LIKE THE WORST CAT OUT THERE!!! She ended up dying for the mary-sue and I thought that was rubbish. 

Well we all done with Bluestar.

Hey, future Dusky. I wanted to say that when I wrote this I was unaware that Bluestar chasing Thristleclaw out of the forest wasn't true but I do know now. I also have come to realize Firestar isn't the 'worst cat out there'.