Previously on Escape The Night All Stars:

Safiya Nygaard, Roi Fabito and Destorm Power all were put to the test and fight for their lives. Luckily two of them got to live unlike last time. Safiya and Roi were them two. Though Destorm unfortunately had died.

(P.s. If you don't like swear words don't listen to the video above.)

"SO Destorm is dead....." Gabbie sighed, "I mean never wanted you guys to die but..... still."

Suddenly the Gingerbread Women returned.

(R.I.P Liza Koshy. Dollar Store queen.)

"OH NO. NOT YOU." Liza yelled as she looked at the women she through in the oven. The women scoffed and called a very familiar name, "SAMPSON!"  Most of the people looked sad at him. His fingers were still cut off by The Gingerbread Women.

"Ok, what do you want?" Joey asked keeping everyone behind him. "I lost my meat pie recipe that was 'salty." She glared at Tyler. "I want it back."

They all nod. "Anything else?" Jesse asked. "I want an amputated arm." She responded. Manny hit Jesse's arm. "You just had to ask." He hissed. "Only people I've seen before can look for them." *Jesse, Lauren, Lizzie and Lauren W. are takin out of the game with the season 1 and 3 cast*.

Recipe Group: Liza, Joey and Tyler.

Arm Pair: Gabbie and Alex.

Recipe Group#############

Liza Joey and Tyler walked into the dinning room. A note was placed on a plate. 'Eat up.' It had said.

There behind it was a cherry pie. Joey grabbed a knife and cut it into thirds. "Cheers." Tyler said. They all bit in until Liza said, "Girl this has something in it. Ya nasty." Joey pulled it out and it was part of the recipe.

"Good job Liza!!" Joey said. "Wow. I never thought I'd be congratulated for eating food." She said. "Can we still eat this?"

The draw behind the opened. And ofcorse another clue was in side. "Ashes in clay and stars show at day.' What does that mean?" Tyler read/asked.

"The Sun is a star so look for a Sun." Liza said.

They were all looking in crooks and crannies trying to find this 'sun'. Until Liza looked up at the glass stained windows. One caught her eye. It had a sunset when she realized they where looking for a Sun.

"Joey! Look, can you get that sunset, I can't reach it." She yelled. "Awwww, you small bean." He giggled at her tininess.

She did a sarcastic laugh and playfully punched his arm. He played along and said, "Oww. That hurt Liza." "Than don't call me small!!" They all laughed and got the glass(house. I gotta stop with these Gabbie Hanna songs.) sun.

"One down. We just need the ashes in clay." Tyler read.

They nodded when Joey opened a cabinet. "I FOUND IT! HERE IT IS!" He yells ,excited. It was an urn.

And ,ofcorse, an instruction was in side of the drawer that had opened.

"'Put the glass in the centre of the table and then poor the ashes around and on it pour an X. If you do it wrong the harpies will come and slice your throats. Sounds familiar, eh Liza.' Oh my god." Joey said. "We've gotta do it Wright or we die." Tyler added.

Liza sighed and face plammed the wall. They did it anyway and luckily
Got it right!!

They were then transported to the others.

Arm Pair/////////////////////////

Gabbie and Alex then had to find the arm. "What if we had to amputate someone?" Gabbie began to freak out, "What if it was our arms?"

Alex had a questionable face as he stared at her. He shook his head and let a small chuckle, "Lets just get this over with." She nodded along and walked to the graveyard. What was there left them horrified.

There were gravestones for their friends. (For example)

On one of the gravestones was a note saying that they had to dig up one of their deceased friends and cut of the arm.

"Well Nikita is out of the question she doesn't even have a body." Gabbie started, " I don't know what to do......"

They had decided to get Tanas. They began to dig. "I hit something." Alex said. They wiped off the dirt and began to pull out the coffin. "Wait so we are actually going to cut her arm off?? This is inhumane!" Gabbie yelled.

"Do you want to die?" Alex asked her. She shook her head ,'no'. "Exactly it's doing this or die. That is what the note said."

Gabbie closed her eyes as she felt the blood splatter on her clothes.  She took a piece of cloth from the floor and wrapped it up. They brought it back.

"Oh my god." Lizzie gasped. Andrea stood up in shock as Mat walked over to them and hugged them. "What do we do now?" Jesse asked. Tim simply shrugged his shoulders in response, "I just wanna get home and feed my cat."

The Gingerbread Women walked in and snatched the arm off of Alex. She then said, "This will be good for a few pies. Vote in two to eat these pies." She then exited.

Voting~

Shane: Jesse.

Andrea: Justine

Justine: Eva

Sierra: Tim

Matt: Lele

Tim: Jesse

Lele: Matt

Eva: Jesse

Oli: Gabbie

Lauren: Jesse

Jesse: Alex

Liza: Manny

Gabbie: Alex

Alex: Jesse

Tyler: Matt

Roi: Himself

Colleen: Tim

Safiya: Lauren W.

Rosanna: Andrea

Manny: Lizzie (sorry)

Matpat: Matt

Lizzie: Herself

Lauren W.: Jesse

Joey: Lele

"I will shuffle then pick two." She started. She shuffled for about a minute, making sure to mix all the cards. "Jesse." He nodded,"That is OK." "And Matt." He shrugged.

They entered a VERY familiar dining room, "Last time I saw pie it had a mannequin toe in it." Matt commented. "I don't remember the last time I had pie." Jesse replied.

They both laughed and saw the pie. "So this was made with Tanas arm......" Jesse realized.

They both started to slowly eat it. "This is surprisingly good." Matt commented. "You're not a cannibal are you?" Jesse jokingly said.

They Both finished and a drawer opened. "'You both don't complain nor make a fuss so I'll let you live BUT you must write down two names of the people you wish to perish in the notebook.'" Jesse read.

"I know you like Gabbie but she has it for me." He said. "Alot of people have it for you." Matt replied, "but Lele is the one person hating on me. So we should put her in."

Jesse didn't have a good enough argument so he nodded and had written her name. "I want to write Justine ( SO SORRY 😭😭😭)." Jesse concluded.

They just waited for the screams to end and then they went out.

"IT WAS JUST LIKE WITH GLOZELL!" Sierra said. "You killed them!" Oli yelled. "We had to, I'm sorry." Matt defended Jesse and himself.

They all just sat down after that. They lost a fighter.

R.I.P Lele Pons and Justine Ezarik.

Roles: The Witch and The Nun.

Cause of Death: Chocked on blood/ Betrayed.

Last Words: Lele: I just don't trust him.
Justine: Wait so they have to eat a human pie??