Plushtrap never thought that he would become a traitor to the nightmares, but the one who he thought was gone had taken him someplace sacred. Plushy couldn’t speak aloud because he would alert anyone who was nearby.

The one who had taken Plushy had only one thing in mind, and that was to protect the child who was coming because of his family, but he didn’t think that Plushtrap would listen to him, this was a major surprise to him.

Plushtrap looked into the eyes of revenge once he was told what to do, he needed to sit in a chair at the end of a hallway and wait for the child to come and beat him at his own game. The reason why is because if the child wins the game, and it will be a sure thing too, they’ll get to sleep for hours before battling against the nightmares themselves.

They both agreed that there’d be many nights involved, but once the next hunters come, the Halloween Nightmares, Nightmare BB will take Plushtrap’s place. So they both came up with the idea to take him once the switch begins so they have a chance to explain and make sure nothing goes wrong.

Once Plushy returned to the nightmares who didn’t know he was gone, he turned and looked at Nightmare BB to see his motivation on hunting and killing, even though he couldn’t kill anyways. He looked at the three leaders, Nightmare Fredbear, Nightmare, and Nightmarionne and wondered if one of them would listen to this idea.

He walked up to them, but before he did, he grabbed Nightmare BB and they both walked up to them. The leaders of the groups looked down at them and asked what they wanted.

Plushtrap responded with his idea for their hunt, “This is an idea for Nightmare BB and I, what if we both played a little game with the child where we can’t kill them but they will get scared before the night.”

“And your point is what?” Nightmare asked them both with a look that he didn’t like what was going on and that he didn’t want to be disturbed.

“Well, if one of us catches the child and scares them, they’ll be in a bigger panic, but if we are caught then they get to sleep for two hours and that’ll make you guys more active and ready as they’ll be tired from that sleep. Even Nightmare BB can be a little more aggressive than me, and faster too!”

“Hmm, I don’t know about this, we have never done that before,” Nightmare said.

“Yah and it could go wrong, but he has good points to it too.” Nightmarionne claimed.

“Okay, we’ll try it, if it works out with tests, then we are going with this plan, if not you both will be kicked out or worse. Being killed like our traitor four armed nightmare.” Nightmare said, agreeing only making the threat so that everything goes right.

“O-okay then, that’s settled so we will both go and plan out what we should do for the hunt!” Plushtrap said with excitement.

They left the leaders to continue planning the hunt, Nightmare Fredbear was the leader of Nightmare Freddy, Bonnie, Foxy, Chica, and Plushtrap. Nightmare was the leader of also Nightmare Fredbear’s group including him. Nightmarionne leads the Halloween Animatronics, Jack-o-Bonnie, Jack-o-Chica, Nightmare BB, and Nightmare Mangle. They all didn’t like it when something goes wrong, so they were the hardest to make a plan with anytime.

Plushtrap was surprised that they even agreed to his plan, the one who takes in ideas more was Nightmare Fredbear and Nightmarionne as they both do what they want. Nightmare Fredbear needs to ask Nightmare before the plan works, but Nightmarionne doesn’t as he has no leader and sometimes bosses Nightmare around.

Nightmarionne from what Plushtrap saw was the only leader who was nicer to try others plans, he also claims that his group are only their own because they were made on Halloween while others weren’t. Plushtrap was in his group in his own way, but he stayed with the Nightmare’s clan instead.

Nightmare Thing was never in any group, he never was allowed to hunt, he couldn’t suggest anything to anyone. He was always tortured for doing his own thing, so no wonder why he betrayed to help the shadows, he felt more included then. Plushtrap now saw this as he is not in any group anymore and is only with the one who is helping both him and the child who would be food for the nightmares.