~Y/N POV~

After grabbing the stuff from "Red Hot Pussy Liquor", I got into a costume where I was wearing a wig with a nightgown, armed myself with a chef's knife, and some slippers.

Why would I dress like this? Let's say Baby loves the classic horror films and one of her favorites was Alfred Hitchcock's "Psycho" from 1963. I was basically dressed up like Norman Bates' "mother", which I think is very fitting due to the fact that I went from a nice and polite young man to now this.

Baby and Karen were wearing these white dresses and I thought they looked so pretty in that!

Grandpa Hugo was dressed up as a viking, RJ dressed up as one of the cops, either Nash or Wydell, I don't give a rat's ass who, and Tiny was dressed as a dark and evil wizard.

We were just partying, drinking booze and having fun while Jerry, Mary, and Denise were dressed up in rabbit costumes, tied up and gagged, just the way I like it!

Baby was giving me a sip of the booze as I drunk it as I kept having fun with this party!

As soon as we stopped, we saw Otis on the stairs, wrapped in a fur coat and that old geezer's skin and he spoke as we waited for him to walk down the stairs.

Otis: I'm the one who brings the Christmas candy.

I saw the three former friends look up at Otis as I was loving what I was seeing.

Otis: Now tell me, who's your daddy?

We all welcomed him down with open arms as he continued his little Shakespeare-like poem.

Otis: I'm the one who brings the Devil's brandy.

Karen: Who's your daddy?

As he kept walking down the stairs and now onto the ground floor...

Otis: I'm the one who beats you when you're bad.

Baby: Who's your daddy?

Karen: Who's your daddy?

Y/N: Who's your daddy!

When Otis was done giving Denise a force kiss on her cheek, he yelled...

Otis: And I'm the one who loves ya when you're fucking dead!

Denise screamed and sobbed with fear as all of us laughed and kept saying "Who's your daddy" over and over again! It was like Christmas, even though it's Halloween.

Otis: Well, I say my little darlings, maybe it ain't a good idea to be prancing around where you don't belong.

He got to Jerry as I was just enjoying myself with the others and we were in joy of this happening in front of.

Otis: And you, the rusher of fools, what was it that you were after? Come on, speak to me, boy!

Jerry was going in and out of consciousness as Otis kept belittling him, much to my delight.

Y/N: I know what he was after, Otis: Dr. Satan!

Otis: That's correct, Y/N, and goddammit, everybody got to know about Dr. Satan. You know what Y/N and I are gonna do? We're gonna do you a favor. We're gonna let you meet the old bastard!

Then, Otis pulled up the mask and said something that made me happy.

Otis: It's all true. The bogeyman is real, and you found him.

Then, we all rounded up these three little rabbits and started walking to a very specific path. I don't know exactly know where we're going, but I know for a fact that we were going to kill them in the most brutal way possible.

Baby noticed my excitement as she came over to me with her signature cute smile.

Baby: How you enjoying it so far?

Y/N: Can't wait to see these fucking assholes get what they deserve.

Baby: I bet you are. When all of this is over, you and I are going to have so much fun.

Y/N: Looking forward to it.

When we got to this huge ass well with a huge coffin made for three people, Jerry, Denise, and Mary were in line as all of us were laughing and ready to sacrifice these three assholes.

Actually, it's two bitches and one asshole, just to remind myself.

RJ lifted the lid and Otis was gesturing Jerry to go first, but I had a better idea.

Y/N: Hey Otis.

Otis: Yeah?

Y/N: Let one of these bitches go first!

Baby, Otis, and Karen seemed to like that idea as Denise was up first instead.

Otis: Okay, happy girl, step your ass up here!

Baby: Take her gag out. It's more fun with the screaming!

Karen: I like that too. That screaming is much more exciting that way!

I pulled Denise's gag off as she was whimpering and begging us to let them go.

Denise: Please don't kill us. Please don't kill us.

And Baby was mocking her as Otis wasn't having it.

Otis: Shut your mouth and get your shit in the box!

He then wielded a gun at her as I lowered it for him.

Y/N: Hold on, there. I wanna say goodbye first.

Otis: Be my fucking guest.

Denise: Just let us go, Y/N. I swear to God we won't tell anyone.

Y/N: You see, this is the problem with simple minded people like you. People like you Denise play on this God thing too much. God ain't helping anyone while there's chaos going on in this country, especially when you're about to be sacrificed!

Denise: Y/N, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Please let us go. We'll forget everything we've done and said about you. We won't treat you like shit anymore, I promise. We promise!

I walked around, making it look like I'm thinking about what Denise just said, but I already know the answer to her question.

When I looked at her hopeful face with tears and blood, I looked directly into her eyes, and said...

Y/N: No.

...while shaking my head and I punched her jaw as she dropped to the ground like a sack of potatoes.

Jerry went crazy, managed to get at me, but before he could attack me I knees his ribs, I felt like I broke them in the process as Mary escaped.

Otis: Where does she think she's gonna run to? She gonna run all the way home?

Baby: No, let Y/N and I get her.

Otis: Oh all right, go get her.

Baby and I nodded as we both ran after Mary.

~Vignette~

Otis: Huntin' humans, ain't nothin' but nothin'. They all run like scared little rabbits.

~End of Vignette~

Baby and I chased after Mary as we kept smiling and having fun with this chase.

~Vignette~

Otis: Run, rabbit, run. Run, rabbit. Run, rabbit. Run, rabbit. Run, rabbit, run! Run, rabbit!

~End of Vignette~

I saw Mary trip and fall in a cemetery where I believe that the victims of the Fireflys. Baby and I moved around her, trying to scare her into a false sense of security.

While we did that, Baby started citing a nursery rhyme.

Baby: There once was a woman who lived with her daughter in a cabbage garden.

I moved behind her and then disappeared before Mary could see me.

Baby: Along came a rabbit and ate up all the cabbages.

Baby kept citing the rhyme as we played mind games with this bitch.

Baby: The woman said, "Go into the garden and drive out the rabbit." Mary.

I decided to join in on this as this was the most fun I've had in a while!

Y/N: Told you. We're gonna get you. Mary.

I even decided to pipe in a nursery rhyme, that sounds kinda fucked up, and what is that rhyme? Well, sorta like this...

Y/N: Mary had a little lamb, little lamb, little lamb
Mary had a little lamb, whose fleece was red as blood... HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA!

Baby: We're gonna get you. We're coming to get you!

Baby cackled as we both appeared out of nowhere tackled Mary as Baby started stabbing Mary almost to the point that both our costumes were covered in her blood.

Then, Baby gave me her knife as I stabbed Mary too in her stomach, as it wasn't enough, I ripped the rabbit hood off her head, extended her neck, and slit her throat before I stood up, licked the blood off the knife, and smiled with such joy. If that's not joy, then I don't know what is.

As Baby cackled one last time, and finished her nursery rhyme.

Baby: "Shoo, shoo," said the maiden. "Come, maiden," said the rabbit. "Sit on my tail and go with me to my rabbit hutch."

I gave the knife back to Baby who licked the blood of the blade as well.

We then looked at each other with a smile, and then we started making out and groping each other, regardless of Mary's corpse next to us.

Little did we know, this was going to be a long fucking night.